Tried & Tested - Scholl

I've been using Garnier's Foot Cocoon for years and swear buy it. I even had it shipped out when I was in the USA.This time around I bought this and it's not as good.Costs more and you get less and it may do what Foot Cocoon does in that it moisturises your feet, but not for as long. It certainly doesn't do what it promises, which is softens hard skin so I still have to go to the chiropodist.I'd love to hear of any products you have tried that haven't worked - and those that have!